The economic categories he employed were those of the classical British economics of David Ricardo, but Marx used them in accordance with his dialectical method to argue that bourgeois society, like every social organism, must follow its inevitable path of development. Paul Kengor: Here’s a quick pop quiz for you: Who said this? It’s well-known that Marxism spawned a host of malformed children, many of whom fought madly against one another. If we’re just going ad hominem, we should add that his hair and beard were messy. The term was used by Karl Marx in various published writings from the 1840s to the 1860s, and also by Friedrich Engels. “Those who say that Karl Marx,” states Dr. Paul Kengor, author of The Devil and Karl Marx, “was somehow doing Christian social justice or some such nonsense make fools of themselves.”, September 1, 2020 Charakter? Paul Kengor: Very simple: Because the political left, which dominates education and especially our universities, does not focus on it. “And why even of yourselves, do you not judge that which is just?” Jesus Christ, Luke 12:57, No, I want to know everything about the person who is proposing a new philosophy, a new belief, an orientation. Now, we have an entire generation of young people born after the Berlin Wall (Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez was literally an infant when the Berlin Wall fell) who have been completely miseducated about the horrors of Marxism and socialism. Thank you for posting interesting content without “spoiling” the book. He was a bigot, a racist, an anti-Semite, and a sexist. Although Marx stressed economic issues in his writings, his major impact has been in the fields of sociology and history. Most troubling, there was an attempt to infiltrate Catholic seminaries. Rory Kinnear plays Marx and Oliver Chris, Engels. I prefer the ‘male’ sex among children who will be born at this turning point in history.”. Marx’s two surviving daughters committed suicide in joint suicide pacts with their husbands. Why do cultists such as Jim Jones have such avid followers? Karl Marx was an idealist. I walk through those claims very carefully. We are within our rights to judge the system of thought that is Marxism. Imagine that. In Marxist philosophy, a character mask (German: Charaktermaske) is a prescribed social role that serves to conceal the contradictions of a social relation or order. CWR: Why do you think we hear so little about the atrocities of communism? (function($) {window.fnames = new Array(); window.ftypes = new Array();fnames[0]='EMAIL';ftypes[0]='email';fnames[3]='MMERGE3';ftypes[3]='text';fnames[1]='FNAME';ftypes[1]='text';fnames[2]='LNAME';ftypes[2]='text';fnames[4]='MMERGE4';ftypes[4]='text';fnames[5]='MMERGE5';ftypes[5]='text';fnames[6]='MMERGE6';ftypes[6]='number';fnames[7]='MMERGE7';ftypes[7]='radio';}(jQuery));var $mcj = jQuery.noConflict(true); Cardinal Dolan urges remembrance of persecuted Christians at Christmas, Vatican’s liturgy congregation stresses importance of Sunday of the Word of God, Eight elderly religious sisters die of coronavirus in Wisconsin, Citing timing, SCOTUS declines to allow in-person learning to resume in Kentucky, Spanish parliament advances legal euthanasia, despite Catholic opposition, Why would anyone stay in a church that "mandated" annual confessions or forced people to donate a certain amount of…. Karl Marx. “The emancipation of the Jews, in the final analysis, is the emancipation of mankind from Judaism.” No, not Hitler. CNN? Navigation ... Karl Marx. Thank you. ... Might have to make that my third character, in case the other two die. Karl Marx was obviously an awful human being. ... Hey, ich muss eine ausführliche Präsentation über Karl Marx bzw. Then I have a question for you. He married Jenny von Westphalen in 1843. Belarusian archbishop surprised to be barred from his homeland. Click here for more information on donating to CWR. The most important lesson from 83,000 brain scans | Daniel Amen | TEDxOrangeCoast - Duration: 14:37. It’s quite telling that in his essay declaring religion “the opium of the people,” Marx said that “the criticism of religion is the beginning of all criticism.” Marx had a favorite quote from Goethe’s Faust: “Everything that exists deserves to perish.” In a letter to Arnold Ruge he called for the “ruthless criticism of all that exists.”. A philosopher known for The Communist Manifesto. Karl Marx (5 May 1818 - 14 March 1883) was a political theorist who conceived of the idea of communism and outlined it in The Communist Manifesto. He already put the poor woman through hell via his refusal to work. Print. “This union of Jew and German on a Negro base was bound to produce an extraordinary hybrid.” Or this: “[He] has the blemish customarily found in the negro tribe—no sense of shame, by which I mean shame about making a fool of oneself.” Answer: No, not the grand wizard of the KKK, but Karl Marx. It isn’t pretty. Ever heard of this? Religion is to be eradicated, because it debilitates and opiates the proletariat. Paul Kengor: It has prompted me to write many books on the subject, and countless articles. On completion of hisdoctorate in 1841 Marx hoped for an academic job, but he had alreadyfallen in with too radical a group of thinkers and the… Answer: because the left likes him. They will scream until they’re blue in the face about gender theory, queer theory, critical theory, “intersectionality,” you name it. I think Mao behaved in that general fashion while pretending to speak as God. Marx took up the very different versions of socialism current in the early 19th century and welded them together into a doctrine that continued to be the dominant version of socialism for half a century after his death. Marx’s particular judgment was rendered by Jesus Christ. Between his birth in 1818 and his death sixty-five years later, Karl Marx became one of Western civilization’s most influential political philosophers. How did communist ideology infiltrate into Roman Catholic seminaries? Karl Marx: A Nineteenth-Century Life, Jonathan Sperber Jonathan Sperber (born 26 December 1952) is an American professor emeritus at the University of Missouri and author of modern European History. arguments at us in maintaining an alleged illegitimacy of our beloved Church. Short summary describing this character. The judgment of Marx himself is reserved for a higher jurisdiction. Emboldened by those successes, communists then went after the Roman Catholic Church in the 1930s, specifically via Communist Party USA’s so-called “outstretched hand” effort. His wife wished that she and her children were safely in their graves, as their lives on earth were hell. Was that even feasible? . Sexist. Ines Angeli Murzaku His ugly statements against blacks and Jews are notorious. Marx and Engels and Lenin would have been aghast as well. Summary. Those who say that Karl Marx was somehow doing Christian social justice or some such nonsense make fools of themselves. Why let your personal political prejudices show your bigotry. Marx was a combination of the Promethean rebel and the rigorous intellectual. Atheist–he’s not the one who deleted “under God” from the Pledge; The champion of the proletariat never paid Lenchen a penny. Paul Kengor: This is a major part of the book, and perhaps one of the most halting sections of the book for churchgoing Christians. John Knox, They didn’t listen. 33 CWR: The situation in Marx’s household was desperate, to say the least. hmm. Paul Kengor: Marx understood that to initiate the revolution, the Judeo-Christian foundation needed to be razed. However, the judgment of his behavior and the damage it caused is the responsibility of all disciples of Christ, just as He exhorted. CWR: For Marx and Marxists, nothing matters but the material world as revealed in the present. Many millions and millions of marked & unmarked graves worldwide of the victims of Marx’s Evil ideology can attest to these crimes against humanity and Gods creations.Why just in the United States alone.We can point to well over 60 Million Souls erased from life since 1972-73.The War against our Catholic Faith has taken a large step forward since the COVID-19 Pandemic.As Parishes were Shuttered & Closed and even today continue to be degraded by States with Marxist/democrat governors as only a small percentage are allowed to enter in masked servitude to these tyrants. Karl truly is one of the most special people … I have not met the man personally, and I doubt you have either. They’ve learned little to nothing about how bad Marxism and Marx were. There is evidence that rather than being an atheist, Karl Marx was actually a theistic Satanist. He was a “small groups” man, most at home in the atmosphere of the General Council or on the staff of a newspaper, where his character could impress itself forcefully on a small body of coworkers. Marx supported violent revolution as the means to ensure social progress. Karl Marx questioned why the owners of these companies are entitled to the hard labor of their workers. CWR: Marx is considered to be a racist and anti-Semite. Hail, Mary! The German revolutionary socialist Karl Marx was also a philosopher, economist, sociologist, and journalist. It’s nearly impossible for that to not be the case. It’s not that typical liberal professors are pro-communist, but, as the late Richard Pipes liked to note, they are anti-anti-communist. He went to no demonstrations, his wife remarked, and rarely spoke at public meetings. Karl’s long-suffering wife was crushed. This always seemed to be aimed at Trump just before an election,hmmm. Some scholars have suggested that Marx was possessed by demons. He observed the cruelties and injustices that the poor working class endured during the period of industrial revolution, and was inspired to write of a society in which no oppression existed for any class of people. Born in Prussia, Marx is the author of Capital (1867-1883) and (with Friedrich Engels) The Communist Manifesto (1848). Other times bad people can accomplish good in spite of themselves. This evil Venom has infiltrated the Supremem Court, our Higher Education, our Health facilities, and our Church. Why was Marx so against religion? Another pop quiz. Exclude Characters Karl Marx (30) Friedrich Engels (10) Adolf Hitler (4) Sonic the Hedgehog (3) Rosa Luxemburg (3) Original Characters (2) Barack Obama (2) Abraham Lincoln (2) Donald Trump (2) Frederick Abberline (2) Exclude Relationships Friedrich Engels/Karl Marx (5) Gender of this character… Was Marx showcasing what socialism had in store for women? Bigot. Or is bigotry excusable because he invented their entire belief system? Here is what he saw and experienced (from this eight-year-old Insight Scoop post): Annuntio vobis gaudium magnum […]. CWR: Why was the Roman Catholic Church so vehemently against communism, opposing this lethal ideology, even before the publication of the Communist Manifesto in 1848? But maybe you don’t care that much? Dr. Kengor recently corresponded about his book and the demonic forces at work in the life and thought of Marx. “Communism begins where atheism begins,” said Karl Marx. Paul Kengor: I deal with that very carefully, and why Marx’s hagiographers have studiously avoided it. Marx’s most important contribution to sociological theory was his general mode of analysis, the “dialectical” model, which regards every social system as having within it immanent forces that give rise to “contradictions” (disequilibria) that can be resolved only by a new social system. In this sense, Marx’s mode of analysis, like those of Thomas Malthus, Herbert Spencer, or Vilfredo Pareto, has become one of the theoretical structures that are the heritage of the social scientist. And, really, the approach here is to say, “Having witnessed a century (and more) of evil, violence, and murder because of communism, let’s take a deeper look at the inner and outer life of the foundational communist thinker.”. “The deeds you do may be the only sermon some persons will hear today” – St. Francis Of Assisi, I strongly recommend that you read the book. Marx’s daughters lived lives of hopelessness and despair. Paul Kengor: I find this so ironic. No need to waste time on someone who has never lived by the principles that he/she teaches. For Jonathan Sperber, a historian of modern Germany, Marx is “more a figure from … With shame narratives of western civilisation – courtesy of cultural Marxism’s influence in universities and schools – becoming the new political and educational orthodoxy, is it any wonder that many young people conceive of Marx as a benign philanthropist and the ideology he articulated as the remedial charter par excellence of economic and social justice? We students back in the 50’s were made aware that the Press would take over, and destroy Christianity. Gender: Male. Much as feudalism replaced capitalism, Marx believed, so would capitalism fall to its own inherent class divides to socialism. Why the self-hate? The second and third volumes, unfinished by Marx, were edited by Engels and published in 1885 and 1894. In this video, Paul Kengor, Professor of Political Science at Grove City College, illuminates the life of the mild-mannered 19th Century German whose ideas led to the rise of some of the most brutal dictators in world history. His father, Heinrich, a successful lawyer, was a man of the Enlightenment, devoted to Kant and Voltaire, who took part in agitations for a constitution in Prussia. He denigrated his son-in-law, Paul Lafargue, of Cuban origin, as “Negrillo” and called him a “Gorilla.” Why did Marx despise blacks and Jews when, in fact, he and his family were of Jewish origin converted to Christianity? If they’d like, they can grab a highlighter and start highlighting passage after passage and quote after quote in my book underlining examples. His mother, born Henrietta Pressburg, was from Holland. Do not tell me your ideas, just show me who you are. It is flatly and factually incorrect and utterly and wholly indefensible. T he other day I stood at the grave of Karl Marx in Highgate cemetery in north London, wondering if he has anything say to us today, 200 years after his birth, on 5 May 1818. Marx believed that this misery would increase, while at the same time the monopoly of capital would become a fetter upon production until finally “the knell of capitalist private property sounds. As his biographer Robert Payne noted, the word almost seems to jump off every page of the Manifesto. How people treat family members matters. He left all of that to Engels, his chief sap, subsidizer, and sugar-daddy. Why did so many follow Hitler? Real Name. All comments posted at Catholic World Report are moderated. Your Trump Derangement Syndrome is showing. Be on the lookout for your Britannica newsletter to get trusted stories delivered right to your inbox. Gender. Karl Marx (May 5, 1818–March 14, 1883), a Prussian political economist, journalist, and activist, and author of the seminal works, "The Communist Manifesto" and "Das Kapital," influenced generations of political leaders and socioeconomic thinkers. The contradictory emotions Marx engendered are reflected in the sometimes conflicting aspects of his character. Frankly, it is shocking, truly hard to believe. Communists had striking success with the penetration of the mainline Protestant denominations, particularly the Episcopal Church, the United Methodist Church, and what became Presbyterian Church USA. I have not delved too deeply, yet already it is evident this is a work about more than the “character flaws” of Karl Marx, but the deeply flawed and diabolical tenets if Communism and its impact on the world to this day. He believed that workers should not be paid less than the product they are creating is worth. He did claim, however, to have proved that each phase in the development of production was associated with a corresponding class structure and that the struggle of classes led necessarily to the dictatorship of the proletariat, ushering in the advent of a classless society. If you value the news and views Catholic World Report provides, please consider donating to support our efforts. The Young Karl Marx (2017) cast and crew credits, including actors, actresses, directors, writers and more. However, beyond his life with Homer almost nothing is known, except that he lives alone. 2. So much for the social principles of Christianity.”, The Roman Catholic Church condemned communism as a “satanic scourge” conceived by “the sons of darkness.” Of socialism, in 1931 Pope Pius XI issued his seminal Quadragesimo Anno, where he stated: “Religious socialism, Christian socialism, are contradictory terms; no one can be at the same time a good Catholic and a true socialist.”, Even Dorothy Day’s The Catholic Worker insisted: “no true Catholic can be a member of the Communist Party.”. This is also true of Donald Trump!”. Above all, Marx was a fighter, willing to sacrifice anything in the battle for his conception of a better society. Beyond ruthless criticism, there was ruthless abolition. Click here to sign up for our newsletter. Did the comeback of socialism urge you to publish the book? Held oder Tyrann? None of them had played much, so we decided to be pretty loose about everything. He lamented to Engels: “My wife, alas, delivered a girl and not a boy.” He later lamented to one of his daughters, who likewise gave birth to a girl: “I congratulate you on the happy delivery…. Causing some desperate parents to even sell their dead children to eat; cannibalism. He gave most persons an impression of intellectual arrogance. Another shadow was cast on Marx’s domestic life by the birth to their loyal servant, Helene Demuth, of an illegitimate son, Frederick; Engels as he was dying disclosed to Eleanor that Marx had been the father. And he ” just” inspired his follower Stalin to murder 20 millions of Russian peasants who were starved to death. That in itself is enough to indicate whether your ideas should, can be followed. “Atheist. He gave most persons an impression of intellectual arrogance. Books, Features, Interview I agree. Marx believed in a revolution that would end socialism and capitalism, and focus on communist principles. In this stunning book, the first comprehensive biography of Marx since the end of the Cold War, Francis Wheen gives us not a socialist ogre but a fascinating, ultimately humane man, while still examining the criticisms of … Marx’s masterpiece, Das Kapital, the “Bible of the working class,” as it was officially described in a resolution of the International Working Men’s Association, was published in 1867 in Berlin and received a second edition in 1873. But “Marx was before all else a revolutionist.” He was “the best-hated and most-calumniated man of his time,” yet he also died “beloved, revered and mourned by millions of revolutionary fellow-workers.”. TEDx Talks Recommended for you MARX, KARL (b.Trier, Prussian Rhineland, 5 May 1818; d. London, England, 14 March 1883) economics, history, philosophy, political science, sociology, history and sociology of science and technology. Was Marx showcasing what socialism had in store for the working class? So when is Antifa/BLM going to start destroying the statues of Herr MArx? MSNBC? When writing The Communist Manifesto, Karl Marx thought he was providing a road to utopia, but everywhere his ideas were tried, they resulted in catastrophe and mass murder. “The Israelite faith is repulsive to me,” said Marx. In 1999, Harvard University Press published The Black Book of Communism: Crimes, Terror, Repression, revealing a “tragedy of planetary dimensions.” It documented the untold atrocities of communism and all the people whose lives and livelihood were crushed by the dictatorship of the proletariat from Stalin’s gulag, to the Chinese Cultural Revolution, to the dictatorships of the proletariat established all over Eastern-Central Europe. Karl is the mysterious guardian angel of Homer. To bring the hymn more in line with Catholic…,, Atheist, racist, bigot, sexist: The truth about the demonic Karl Marx | Catholicism Pure & Simple, “The Best Books I Read in 2020” – Catholic World Report, The significance of the Diocese of Brooklyn case in fighting restrictions, India’s Supreme Court to hear complaint over mandatory confession in Oriental Orthodoxy, ‘All are Welcome’ not a welcome hymn at Mass, USCCB committee says, ‘It doesn’t embarrass us’: Art teacher defends Vatican’s much-maligned nativity scene, Flashback to April 19, 2005: “Qui accipit nomen Benedictus XVI!”. For about 20 years I’ve traveled around the country giving talks on campuses with titles like, “Why Communism Is Bad,” sponsored by the likes of the wonderful Young America’s Foundation. “The judgment of Marx himself is reserved for a higher jurisdiction.”. Bigot–he’s not the one who persecutes, what, “people of religion”; and Alas, for those answers, you’ll have to get the book! Karl had a sexual relationship with the young nursemaid, Helene Demuth, known as “Lenchen.” Actually, it isn’t quite right to say that Lenchen worked for the Marx family, given that she toiled without pay, almost as Karl’s chattel. Why do they have aspirations and ideals that Marx would find repugnant? Karl, who refused to bathe, groom, and suffered from boils all over his body (including his penis), bedded Lenchen behind his wife Jenny’s back. He regarded struggle as the law of life and existence. The man who wrote about the specter of communism that was haunting Europe wrote about the specters and monsters haunting him. He did not deal directly with the ethical issues that occupied the philosophers so far discussed. I recently wrote an article asking why our wondrous progressives in the cancel culture haven’t canceled Karl Marx. Of Christianity, Marx added: “The social principles of Christianity preach cowardice, self-contempt, abasement, submission, humility. There are many, inter-connected reasons, but one is that when people latch onto ideas that make easy sense of certain matters while ignoring other matters altogether they often become slaves (and then tyrants) of those ideologies. Only the first volume was completed and published in Marx’s lifetime. I don’t think Karl Marx was among the latter group though. Payne, a man of arts and literature, not a right-winger, and a respected academic not expected to level such a shocking charge lightly, asserted of Marx: “He had the devil’s view of the world, and the devil’s malignity. Marx was often portrayed by his followers as a scientist rather than a moralist. It would ultimately be more productive to logically point out the flaws of the ideology and not the person(s) associated with it. Marx was a combination of the Promethean rebel and the rigorous intellectual. The word “abolition” is omnipresent throughout Marx’s writings. Karl Marx was born in Trier, in the German Rhineland, in1818. Sure. In a recent book entitled The Devil and Karl Marx: Communism’s Long March of Death, Deception, and Infiltration, Dr. Paul Kengor, professor of political science at Grove City College and senior director and chief academic fellow at the college’s Institute for Faith and Freedom, provides a sophisticated and well-documented analysis of communism by going to the source: Karl Marx. “There were times when Marx seemed to be possessed by demons,” recorded Robert Payne in his seminal 1968 biography of Marx—probably the best and most insightful biography of Marx. I do not hazard to assess whether Marx was, say, possessed, though others have. Racist. Catholic archbishop: ‘The Church in France is jostled from many sides’, Early voting and this election season have raised important questions for Catholics. Put the other way, if the founder of the Church was a violent, nasty, brutish, hateful figure, don’t you think things would have been a bit different the past 2,000 years? Karl Marx. The significance of the Diocese of Brooklyn case in fighting COVID restrictions – Catholic World Report: […] [Editor’s note: On December 17th, after this interview took place, the District of Columbia eased its restrictions after a…, Amazing Grace can give the impression that we are automatically saved. Sad, Indeed — We have been infiltrated with the Smoke of Satan for many years. His favourite daughter, Eleanor, worried him with her nervous, brooding, emotional character and her desire to be an actress. The most memorable pages in Das Kapital are the descriptive passages, culled from Parliamentary Blue Books, on the misery of the English working class. "A brilliant book, by a superb author, about a necessary man. Your email address will not be published. One would expect that “the door to Utopia” of socialism and communism would have effectively closed for good. Did she really say that? And now we’re paying the price. Part 4 is called “Infiltration and Manipulation.” It includes six chapters on the very deliberate and cynical infiltration of churches by communists in the United States, Western and Eastern Europe, and the Soviet Union. If Dr. Kengor and others only relied on analysis of Marx’s personality and life to attack Marxism, then you’d have a fair point. Why? In his seminal edited volume on Karl Marx and religion, Saul Padover said that Marx represented “what the Germans call Selbsthass (self-hate), a trait which Karl Marx displayed throughout his whole life.”. Who said this? And who can deny that his character and actions don’t deeply inform and shape (or at least should) every aspect of Catholic life and belief? Summary. Undoubtedly, the most influential socialist thinker to emerge in the 19th century, he did not achieve much fame during his lifetime but his popularity soared in the decades following his death. Bigot. Sometimes he seemed to know that he was accomplishing works of evil.” Read my book and you’ll get an exhaustive walk through all of that ugliness. Karl Marx: A Nineteenth-Century Life – Jonathan Sperber. They would prefer to condemn anti-communists rather than condemn pro-communists. Why does Marx get a pass? does he also abuse his wife, drive his children to despair & never bathe? I rather doubt the same is true of Trump, or his followers. Character » Karl Marx appears in 43 issues. If we are going to follow Mr Kengor’s and Ms. Murzaka’s approach, than it’s fair game when critics of the Catholic Church through the evil popes/pedophile priests/etc. Was she capable? den Marxismus und seine Lösung der Sozialen Frage halten. “Bourgeois” historians, he acknowledged, had described them long before he had. Communism just doesn’t register very loudly on their outrage meter. Marx is considered by historians to be the founder of Communism. "―Christopher Hitchens. The influence of Marx’s ideas has been enormous. But sometimes bad people have bad ideas. Racist–his is the Administration that for “people of color” reduced the unemployment rate to the lowest in our history (except when the other party defended full-employment slavery); Why must be it an “either/or” approach? Sign up to receive a weekly email with news, analysis, and commentary from a voice you can trust! Short summary describing this character. Simply put, if a worker is creating 3 widgets an hour that are worth $5 each, then their work is worth $15. He looked down upon women. Karl Heinrich Marx was a German philosopher, economist, historian, sociologist, political theorist, journalist and socialist revolutionary. The judgment of Marx himself is reserved for a higher jurisdiction. Neo-Marxists, who no longer accept the economic reasoning in Das Kapital, are still guided by this model in their approach to capitalist society. Sexist–he’s among those who still marry people of the opposite sex, and who defends the right-to-live of unborn girls. Karl Marx and Frederick Engels: letters to Americans, 1848-1895;: A selection by Karl Marx: Karl Marx and the development of his work: 1818-1841 by Michael Heinrich: Karl Marx on India: From the New York Daily Tribune Including Articles by Frederick Engels and Extracts from Marx-engels Correspondence 1853-1862 by Iqbal Husain Besides, in their view, the communists had many “good” intentions. But if in Germany the empirical and scientific tradition in philosophy lay dormant, in France and England in the middle of the 19th century it was very much alive.…, Hegel was a conservative, but his influence on the revolutionaries. He was a great reader of novels, especially those of Sir Walter Scott and Balzac; and the family made a cult of Shakespeare.